News

Are Awards Still Challenge-Proof in the DIFC?

 

Dubai Arbitration Week (DAW) | Dubai | 9 – 13 November 2026

Recent decisions of the DIFC Courts have renewed attention on the circumstances in which arbitral awards may be challenged. For parties, counsel, and tribunals, the question is not simply how to secure a favorable award, but how to ensure that the award is reached through a process capable of withstanding scrutiny and ultimately being enforced.

On 11 November 2026, during Dubai Arbitration Week, Hourani & Partners hosted “Are Awards Still Challenge-Proof in the DIFC?”, bringing together senior perspectives from private practice, the Bar, and in-house legal leadership to examine this issue.

Moderated by R. Carter Parét, Counsel at ZH Partners*, the panel featured Daniel Xu, Partner at Hourani & Partners; Rupert Reed KC of Serle Court; and Adriaan Hoeben, Vice President Arbitration at Dubai Holding. The discussion considered the new enforcement landscape in the GCC in light of recent DIFC Court cases, the evolving approach of the UAE onshore courts, balancing procedural fairness, obtaining and enforcing interim relief, and the practical steps that clients, counsel, and tribunals can take to help make an award “stick.”

A Changing Landscape for Award Challenges

The discussion began with the legal framework governing challenges to arbitral awards in the UAE.

Daniel Xu examined the relationship between the DIFC Arbitration Law and the UAE’s federal arbitration framework, as well as the increasingly arbitration-friendly approach of the onshore courts. Drawing on his experience defending a recent challenge in the DIFC Courts that progressed to the Court of Appeal, he considered how the newer federal framework is contributing to greater predictability around challenges, set-aside applications, and enforcement.

This development is particularly significant because the choice between a DIFC and an onshore UAE seat has historically influenced how parties assess challenge and enforcement risks. The panel observed that the position continues to evolve, with both the DIFC and onshore courts demonstrating greater familiarity with arbitration and a general reluctance to interfere with awards in the absence of a clear legal or procedural deficiency.

However, a more arbitration-supportive environment does not make awards immune from challenge. It places greater emphasis on whether the arbitration was conducted in accordance with the parties’ agreement, the applicable law, and fundamental procedural safeguards.

What Recent DIFC Decisions Tell Us

Rupert Reed KC led the discussion on recent DIFC Court decisions and the grounds on which awards may be set aside under the DIFC Arbitration Law.

The panel’s preparatory framework identified Oheo Bank v Parker and Princeton v Persephone as central to this part of the discussion, with particular emphasis on procedural irregularities and the standard as to when procedural irregularities can rise to the level of a challenge.

The broader lesson was that obtaining the “right” substantive result is not sufficient. An award may still be exposed if the procedure followed by the tribunal does not give each party a proper opportunity to present its case.

As Rupert Reed KC emphasized during the discussion: “It’s not just about getting the right result, it’s about making sure that the tribunal gets to the right result by the right process.”

This principle is especially relevant when a tribunal is dealing with late arguments, new authorities, or issues raised after the evidentiary hearing. If an award is likely to turn on an issue that one party has not had a fair opportunity to address, the safer course may be to pause the process and allow for a full briefing, even if that extends the timetable.

Why Short-Term Procedural Advantages Can Create Long-Term Risk

Procedural efficiency is important, but efficiency should not come at the expense of fairness.

The panel considered how accelerated timetables, restricted opportunities to respond, and pressure to move quickly toward an award may create future challenge risk. This is particularly important in document-heavy construction and commercial disputes, where a party may require sufficient time to retrieve historical records, instruct new counsel, or respond to a newly developed case.

A party may secure a short-term tactical advantage by opposing an extension or pressing for an unusually compressed timetable. However, that advantage can become counterproductive if the resulting award is challenged on the basis that the other party was unable properly to present its case.

The practical takeaway is that parties and counsel should assess procedural decisions not only by reference to their immediate strategic benefit, but also by asking whether the resulting process will remain defensible after the award is issued.

The Client Perspective: Build Resilience from the Outset

Bringing the in-house and onshore Dubai perspective to the discussion, Adriaan Hoeben, Vice President Arbitration at Dubai Holding, focused on finality and the measures that parties can take from the beginning of an arbitration to reduce challenge risk.

Adriaan Hoeben emphasized that tribunal selection is central to that assessment. Parties should consider not only an arbitrator’s legal and sector expertise, but also their availability, procedural judgment, and ability to manage the case fairly and decisively.

The appointment of an experienced chair is particularly important. A strong chair can maintain momentum while ensuring that the timetable remains realistic and that both parties are given an appropriate opportunity to present their cases. One of Adriaan Hoeben’s key takeaways was to not just rely on default rules for chair selection, but have the parties involved.

As Adriaan Hoeben observed: “A strong chair will generally avoid procedural irregularities that lead to challenge down the road.”

This reflects a wider point: challenge risk should not be treated as a post-award issue. It should form part of the arbitration strategy from the beginning through to the final submissions and drafting of the award.

Interim Relief: Where Tribunal and Court Powers Intersect

The discussion also examined the practical difficulties surrounding interim relief, including freezing orders, precautionary attachments, and measures intended to preserve assets or disputed funds.

These applications often sit at the intersection of arbitral authority and court jurisdiction and straddle the difference between a court’s supervisory and enforcement jurisdiction. The key questions may include:

  • Whether the measure should be sought directly from a court or first ordered by the tribunal;
  • Which court has supervisory jurisdiction over the arbitration;
  • Which court has enforcement jurisdiction over the relevant assets;
  • Whether the requested measure affects matters traditionally regarded as falling within the courts’ exclusive territory; and
  • How recognition and enforcement may differ across the DIFC, onshore UAE, Saudi Arabia, and other regional markets.

Carter Parét brought a Saudi perspective to this part of the discussion, helping to position the issue within a wider regional enforcement context rather than treating the DIFC and onshore Dubai as isolated jurisdictions. The panel considered how a tribunal-ordered measure may follow a different enforcement route from a direct application for court relief, and why due-process compliance remains important even at the interim stage.

Six Practical Steps to Help an Award Withstand Challenge

The discussion identified six practical measures that parties and counsel should consider throughout an arbitration:

  1. Select the tribunal carefully

Consider relevant expertise, availability, procedural experience, and the ability of the chair to manage complex or fast-moving proceedings.

  1. Adopt a realistic timetable

Efficiency should not prevent either party from properly preparing and presenting its case, particularly in complex or document-intensive disputes.

  1. Protect the right to be heard

Where new arguments, evidence, or authorities arise, ensure that the affected party is given an appropriate opportunity to respond, even at the risk of moderating client expectations on smaller procedural victories.

  1. Consider challenge risk when making procedural decisions

A favorable procedural order may not be advantageous if it creates a credible basis for challenging the eventual award.

  1. Plan enforcement and interim relief early

Identify where relevant assets are located, which courts may have jurisdiction, and whether relief should be sought from the tribunal, the courts, or both.

  1. Maintain a clear procedural record

The record should demonstrate that the tribunal considered the parties’ submissions, addressed material procedural requests, and provided a fair opportunity for each party to present its case.

Making Awards “Stick”

The central message from the panel was that the resilience of an arbitral award is built throughout the proceedings, not after the award has been issued.

Careful tribunal selection, realistic timetables, procedural fairness, and early enforcement planning can all reduce the likelihood of a successful challenge. They can also strengthen the award’s credibility when it is placed before a court for recognition or enforcement.

As Rupert Reed KC summarized: “We want an award that’s going to stick.”

That objective is shared by parties, counsel, and tribunals. The aim is not simply to reach the right result, but to reach it through a fair, disciplined, and legally robust process that can withstand subsequent scrutiny.

For more information on challenging or enforcing arbitral awards in the UAE, please contact our Arbitration and Dispute Resolution team.

*Member of ZH Partners, Relationship Firm in Saudi Arabia.

Share this post:
Write a comment:

*

Your email address will not be published.

© 2026 Hourani & Partners. All Rights Reserved.